San
Bernardino's bankruptcy case becomes a battle of titans
Posted:
12/10/2012 09:35:56 AM PST - San Bernardino County Sun
The battle lines
have formed in San Bernardino's effort to enter Chapter 9
bankruptcy protection.
On one side is CalPERS, the state's public employee
retirement system, which is the city's biggest creditor and
brooks no lapse in payments from its member agencies. CalPERS
has challenged San Bernardino's petition for bankruptcy
protection and asked for a reversal of the stay that prevents
lawsuits against the city until its bankruptcy case is
decided.
On the other side is the broke city itself and an
influential if unreliable ally: Wall Street, in the form of
the city's pension-obligation bondholders.
Those bondholders are investors who collectively own more
than $50 million in debt the city issued in 2005 to fund its
obligations to CalPERS. The city still owes $48.6 million on
those pension-obligation bonds.
Attorneys for the bondholders filed a document with the
court rebutting most of the points CalPERS and the San
Bernardino Public Employee Association made in their
objections to the city's bankruptcy filing.
Some expert observers said they expect CalPERS' attempt to
sue San Bernardino for back payments to be rejected by U.S.
Bankruptcy Court. But that's just a skirmish in the overall
war.
The real action revolves around Wall Street's attack on the
primacy of payments to CalPERS. Investors want the retirement
system to be just one of the creditors like everyone else, not
an entity that gets its money before the other creditors fight over the remaining scraps.
See what has happened here? San Bernardino couldn't afford
to make its CalPERS payments as far back as seven years ago.
Instead of making the fiscally sound decision to cut spending,
city leaders borrowed $50.4 million so that the city could
meet its pension payment obligations.
Financial firms were happy to sell those bonds to their
customers, not worrying too much about the possibility that
the city might not be able to pay them back - despite the
ominous sign that San Bernardino was borrowing a huge sum in
order to pay ongoing expenses.
CalPERS, meanwhile, saw no problem in the fact that one of
its member agencies had to borrow tens of millions of dollars
to keep making its pension payments. The pension system
appears untroubled by its huge unfunded liability - officially
$228 billion, higher according to some observers - and the
fact that burgeoning pension payments are pushing more
municipalities toward insolvency, so long as the money keeps
coming in.
City employees were not bothered by the borrowing either,
so long as their pensions kept growing.
For its part, the City Council was improvident enough to
increase the pension-payout formula for safety employees in
2006 and for nonsafety employees in 2007 - after having to
borrow tens of millions to pay for the existing pension plans,
which clearly the city already could not afford.
It's hard to find a hero to root for in this bunch.
San Bernardino's bankruptcy effort is poised to become a
battle of titans because - unlike Vallejo and Stockton - the
city stopped making payments to CalPERS some $6.9 million ago.
CalPERS claims primacy over all other creditors under
California law, but Bankruptcy Court is federal. (Ask former
medical marijuana provider Aaron Sandusky, who could get 10
years to life in federal prison next month for his conviction
for peddling illegal drugs, about differences between state
and federal law.)
Bond sellers and holders see this case as a showdown with
CalPERS, in which they hope to do away with the retirement
system's payoff primacy and gain equal footing as creditors.
That leaves San Bernardino as a pawn in a much bigger game,
where the major players are worried about the money they think
is coming to them - and not really all that concerned about
the city's future.
Copyright
2012 San Bernardino County Sun. All rights
reserved.